Pantry Review Tally

Read Nov 20, 2026.

This page shows the numbers behind the pantry post. For each Target pick, I read the written 1 to 3 star reviews Target shows, up to 200 per product, read on Nov 20, 2026, and sorted each one by what went wrong. That came to 299 low-star reviews.

How to read it

  • One review can count in more than one group, so the counts can add up to more than the reviews read.
  • "Off-topic" covers shipping, store service, stock questions, billing and positive 3-star reviews.
  • Many star ratings have no written text. That's why "written reviews read" is lower than the 1+2+3 star count.
  • The quotes are my paraphrases, not buyers' exact words.
  • Ratings and averages come from Target's rating summary on the same day.
  • Where a product has only a few written low-star reviews, I say the sample is too small to call a pattern.

Summary

Product Ratings Avg 1★ / 2★ / 3★ Written 1–3★ read Top real complaint (count) Size/depth complaints
Brightroom small wide bin 292 4.87 3 / 2 / 3 2 Tie, 1 each: sticker residue, thin plastic, too narrow 1
Brightroom large wide bin 209 4.76 6 / 2 / 5 7 Front sticker will not come off (5) 2
Brightroom open-front bin 2,271 4.87 22 / 8 / 30 7 Arrived scratched or cracked (3) 0
Brightroom seagrass basket, large 466 4.81 10 / 1 / 9 8 Lower quality than expected or than before (3) 2
Brightroom 56 qt bin 458 4.50 38 / 12 / 8 25 Arrived with no lid (9) 0
Rubbermaid Brilliance canisters (8-piece set) 1,767 4.51 91 / 54 / 65 200 (feed cap) Cracks over time (104) 9
OXO lazy Susan 147 4.64 5 / 3 / 6 6 Usable surface smaller than expected (4) 4
Threshold 75 oz glass jar 1,917 4.76 43 / 23 / 46 36 No gasket; lid not airtight or loose (25) 1
Brightroom hyacinth basket, small 965 4.78 15 / 13 / 27 8 Tie, 3 each: strong smell; smaller than expected 3

Brightroom small wide bin (Target item 85318243)

Stats: 292 ratings, average 4.87. 1★: 3, 2★: 2, 3★: 3. Written 1–3★ reviews read: 2.

Category Count
Product sticker leaves residue that will not clean off 1
Plastic feels thin and cheap 1
Too narrow to hold much 1
Off-topic or no real complaint 0

Most common real complaint: None. With only 2 written reviews, each complaint appears once.

What buyers said (my paraphrase):

  • Sticker: Label glue stayed on the bin no matter how she scrubbed.
  • Thin plastic: Bin feels flimsy and could crack with little force.
  • Too narrow: A standard cracker box jammed inside because the bin is not wide.

Size or depth: 1 review. The bin is not wide enough, and a cracker box gets stuck in it.

Brightroom large wide bin (Target item 85318248)

Stats: 209 ratings, average 4.76. 1★: 6, 2★: 2, 3★: 5. Written 1–3★ reviews read: 7.

Category Count
Large front sticker is very hard to remove 5
Wrong size for the space (too deep or not the size expected) 2
Plastic scratched while trying to remove the sticker 1
Off-topic or no real complaint 0

Most common real complaint: The front sticker will not come off (5 of 7).

What buyers said (my paraphrase):

  • Sticker: Big label on the front takes ages and solvent to remove.
  • Sticker damage: Scrubbing off the label left scratches on the clear front.
  • Size: Bin is too deep for the buyer's fridge shelf.

Size or depth: 2 reviews.

  • One buyer says the bin is too deep for a fridge and asks for a shallower version.
  • One buyer found it smaller than expected and also too large for a kitchen drawer. The buyer used it for TV remotes instead.

Brightroom open-front bin (Target item 83279857)

Stats: 2,271 ratings, average 4.87. 1★: 22, 2★: 8, 3★: 30. Written 1–3★ reviews read: 7.

Category Count
Arrived scratched, chipped or cracked (loose online packing) 3
Sharp edges or cracks in use 2
Shows fingerprints and smudges, turns cloudy 1
Off-topic or no real complaint (stock question) 1

Most common real complaint: Bins arrived scratched or cracked after shipping with little padding (3).

What buyers said (my paraphrase):

  • Shipping damage: Online order came barely padded, so the bins hit each other.
  • Sharp edges: Cut plastic at the base left points that could scratch shelves.
  • Smudges: Clear plastic quickly shows prints and dust and looks cloudy.

Size or depth: None. One review asks whether a 12x12x8 size will return to stock. That is a stock question, not a size complaint.

Brightroom seagrass basket, large (Target item 86383685)

Stats: 466 ratings, average 4.81. 1★: 10, 2★: 1, 3★: 9. Written 1–3★ reviews read: 8.

Category Count
Lower quality than earlier purchases, or poor for the price 3
Smaller than expected for a "large" basket 2
Arrived damaged (shipped loose) 2
Weave is prickly or sheds bits 2
Off-topic or no real complaint 0

Most common real complaint: Quality seems lower than older baskets or than the price suggests (3).

What buyers said (my paraphrase):

  • Quality: Newer baskets feel less sturdy than ones bought a few years earlier.
  • Size: Called large, but holds less than the buyer expected for the money.
  • Damage: Online baskets arrived crushed; buyer suggests buying in store.
  • Texture: Woven grass pokes hands and drops small pieces around.

Size or depth: 2 reviews. Both say the basket is smaller than expected. One calls it "nice but too small". The other says it is not very large for the price.

Brightroom 56 qt bin with lid (Target item 93327175)

Stats: 458 ratings, average 4.50. 1★: 38, 2★: 12, 3★: 8. Written 1–3★ reviews read: 25.

Category Count
Arrived with no lid 9
Arrived broken, damaged or with holes 6
Lid supplied does not fit the bin (wrong lid) 4
Thin plastic, breaks easily, or lid does not stay closed 4
Off-topic or no real complaint (returns, pickup, billing, late delivery) 4

Most common real complaint: The bin arrived without its lid (9). With the 4 wrong-lid reports, 13 of 25 reviews are about the lid.

What buyers said (my paraphrase):

  • No lid: Bin showed up alone, so it cannot be used as a closed tote.
  • Damaged: Totes came cracked or holed, often unwrapped in the box.
  • Wrong lid: Lids sent with the order were a different size and did not fit.
  • Thin: Plastic is thinner than other brands, and lids pop open.

Size or depth: No size complaints. One review says the size is great. Note: most complaints are about order fulfilment (missing or wrong lids), not the product design.

Rubbermaid Brilliance canisters, 8-piece set (Target item 53663905)

Stats: 1,767 ratings, average 4.51. 1★: 91, 2★: 54, 3★: 65 (210 ratings). Written 1–3★ reviews read: 200 (85 one-star, 52 two-star, 63 three-star).

Review cap: Target's review feed returned a maximum of 200 reviews for this product. The rating summary lists 210 ratings at 1–3 stars, so up to 10 low reviews may be missing. Dates run from 2017-01-10 to 2026-09-29.

Mismatch warning: Most of these reviews do not appear to be about an 8-piece pantry canister set.

  • Most describe the Brilliance leftovers and lunch containers: microwave reheating, soup leaks in work bags, dishwasher use, and freezer use.
  • Reviewers name other sets and sizes: 10, 14, 18, 20, 36 and 44 piece sets, single 1.3, 3.2, 4.7, 9.6 and 12 cup containers, and the glass version.
  • 19 reviews are marked "collected as part of a promotion". Several of these compare one plastic container with a glass one.
  • Of 1,767 ratings, the summary flags 1,086 as incentivized.
  • Only about 9 reviews clearly describe a pantry or dry-goods set (for example "pantry set", a tall canister for spaghetti, a 4-container box with a missing piece, and flour or sugar storage).
  • Conclusion: Target's feed appears to pool reviews from the whole Brilliance range. Treat the counts below as "Brilliance plastic line", not "this pantry set".
Category Count
Containers or lids crack, split or break over time (including latches and corners snapping) 104
Clouds, stains, keeps odors, warps or bubbles with heat, or is hard to clean 58
Leaks or seal fails; not airtight or leakproof 45
Lid is very hard to open or close 16
Arrived damaged, scratched or missing a piece, or piece count is confusing 11
Size, height, stacking or nesting problems 9
Other single complaints (feels flimsy; packaging glue left on lid) 2
Off-topic or no real complaint (positive promo reviews, prefers glass with no complaint, website price issue, wants only one size) 8

Most common real complaint: Containers and lids develop cracks, often within months, even with hand washing (104 of 200).

What buyers said (my paraphrase):

  • Cracks: Hairline cracks spread through bases and lids within a year of use.
  • Clouding and staining: Clear plastic turns cloudy or picks up sauce and onion smells.
  • Leaks: Seal stops holding, so soup or dressing seeps into lunch bags.
  • Hard to open: Suction lid grips so tight that older buyers struggle to lift it.
  • Arrived damaged or short: Box held scratched containers or one container fewer than listed.

Size or depth (9 reviews):

  • 3 reviews say the tall canister is too short to hold dry spaghetti. These are the most relevant to a pantry post.
  • 3 reviews say containers do not nest or stack, so they take a lot of cabinet space. One says the 12-cup size will not stack with itself or inside the 9-cup.
  • 1 review says nested containers stuck together and were hard to separate.
  • 1 review says lids do not stack and take extra vertical space.
  • 1 review says two 4.7-cup lids did not fit their bases.

OXO lazy Susan (Target item 51471454)

Stats: 147 ratings, average 4.64. 1★: 5, 2★: 3, 3★: 6. Written 1–3★ reviews read: 6.

Category Count
Usable turntable surface is smaller than expected 4
Bulky; takes more cabinet room than it holds 2
Broke after a few months 1
Off-topic or no real complaint 0

Most common real complaint: The space to hold items is smaller than buyers expected (4 of 6).

What buyers said (my paraphrase):

  • Too small: The 11-inch size is the base; the top holds under 9 inches.
  • Bulky: Footprint and height eat cabinet space without holding more.
  • Durability: Plastic gave out after about five months.

Size or depth: 4 reviews, the strongest size theme in this set.

  • 2 reviews say the 11-inch figure is the base, and the usable top is smaller (one measured under 9 inches).
  • 1 review says a 10-inch model from another brand held more.
  • 2 reviews simply call it tiny or too small.
  • 2 reviews say it is bulky in width and height for what it holds.

Threshold 75 oz glass jar (Target item 79474165)

Stats: 1,917 ratings, average 4.76. 1★: 43, 2★: 23, 3★: 46. Written 1–3★ reviews read: 36.

Category Count
No gasket or seal; lid not airtight, loose or slides off 25
Lid or jar cracked, chipped or shattered in use (often after the loose lid fell) 8
Sharp glass edge on the rim; cut fingers 5
Arrived chipped or broken 2
Too small for the intended use 1
Off-topic or no real complaint (store customer service) 1

Most common real complaint: The glass lid has no rubber seal, so the jar is not airtight and the lid slides (25 of 36).

What buyers said (my paraphrase):

  • No seal: Lid just rests on top, so snacks and cookies go stale.
  • Breakage: Loose lid slid off, fell, and shattered into sharp splinters.
  • Sharp rim: Inner lip was rough enough to cut a hand while washing.
  • Arrived chipped: Jars bought in store had chips hidden under the wrap.

Size or depth: 1 review. The buyer says the jar is too small for large bath bombs. One other review praises the size.

Brightroom hyacinth basket, small (Target item 83378544)

Stats: 965 ratings, average 4.78. 1★: 15, 2★: 13, 3★: 27. Written 1–3★ reviews read: 8.

Category Count
Smaller or narrower than expected 3
Strong unpleasant smell that will not air out 3
Sharp pieces inside, or the weave comes apart 2
Off-topic or no real complaint 0

Most common real complaint: A tie at 3 each: the basket smells bad, and it is smaller than expected.

What buyers said (my paraphrase):

  • Smell: Woven material has a strong odor that months of airing did not fix.
  • Size: Basket is narrower and smaller than the listing suggested.
  • Weave: Rough ends poke inside, and the hyacinth frays easily.

Size or depth: 3 reviews.

  • 1 review says a later purchase was smaller than the same basket bought months earlier.
  • 1 review says it is not as wide as listed, and the curved bottom stops items from sitting flat.
  • 1 review says it is not as large as expected.